diff --git a/FINAL_SUMMARY.md b/FINAL_SUMMARY.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7d31825fe --- /dev/null +++ b/FINAL_SUMMARY.md @@ -0,0 +1,106 @@ +# Final Summary - Preinstall Enhancements PR Preparation + +## Status: ✅ READY FOR ISSUE CREATION + +All preparation work is complete. The PR is ready once the Feature Request issue is created. + +## Completed Tasks + +### ✅ Code Implementation +- Enhanced `run_comfyui.bat` with all features +- Created `create_shortcut.ps1` helper script +- All code tested and working + +### ✅ Documentation +- **PR_DESCRIPTION.md**: Complete PR description with all required sections: + - Author's Note + - Related Issue (placeholder for issue number) + - Issue Addressed + - Overview + - Key Features (5 major features) + - Files Changed + - Screenshots (with examples) + - Testing Recommendations (10 scenarios) + - Technical Details + - Backward Compatibility + - Benefits + - Additional Notes + - Potential Concerns and Side Effects + - Request for Review + +- **FEATURE_REQUEST_ISSUE.md**: Complete issue content ready to copy/paste +- **CREATE_ISSUE_INSTRUCTIONS.md**: Step-by-step instructions for creating the issue +- **PR_SUBMISSION_CHECKLIST.md**: Complete checklist with updated steps +- **PR_COMPLIANCE_ANALYSIS.md**: Analysis of compliance with wiki requirements +- **SEARCH_RESULTS_SUMMARY.md**: Documentation of search for existing issues/PRs +- **PREINSTALL_ENHANCEMENTS_PLAN.md**: Plan document + +### ✅ Compliance Verification +- ✅ No sensitive code (`eval()` not used) +- ✅ Clear title and comprehensive description +- ✅ All required sections included in PR description +- ✅ Testing recommendations provided +- ✅ Potential concerns explicitly stated +- ✅ PR size acknowledged with explanation +- ⚠️ Feature Request issue needs to be created (content ready) + +### ✅ Branch Status +- Branch: `preinstall-enhancements` +- Base: `master` +- Status: Clean working tree, all changes committed +- Commits: 7 commits ready +- Files changed: 5 files (+725/-61 lines) + +## Next Steps (In Order) + +1. **Create Feature Request Issue** (REQUIRED) + - Use content from `FEATURE_REQUEST_ISSUE.md` + - Follow instructions in `CREATE_ISSUE_INSTRUCTIONS.md` + - Save the issue number + +2. **Update PR Description** + - Replace placeholder in `PR_DESCRIPTION.md` with actual issue number + - Commit the update + +3. **Push Branch** + ```bash + git push origin preinstall-enhancements + ``` + +4. **Create PR on GitHub** + - Use PR description from `PR_DESCRIPTION.md` + - Reference the issue number + - Add screenshots if available + +## Files Ready for Use + +1. **FEATURE_REQUEST_ISSUE.md** - Copy/paste into GitHub issue +2. **PR_DESCRIPTION.md** - Copy/paste into PR description (after adding issue number) +3. **CREATE_ISSUE_INSTRUCTIONS.md** - Step-by-step guide +4. **PR_SUBMISSION_CHECKLIST.md** - Complete checklist + +## Key Points + +- ✅ All wiki requirements met (except issue creation, which is next step) +- ✅ PR description is comprehensive and includes all required sections +- ✅ No duplicate work found (searched for existing issues/PRs) +- ✅ Code is tested and ready +- ✅ Documentation is complete + +## Compliance Summary + +| Requirement | Status | Notes | +|------------|--------|-------| +| Open Feature Request | ⚠️ Pending | Content ready, needs to be created | +| Single, focused PR | ✅ Compliant | Large but cohesive, explained in PR | +| No sensitive code | ✅ Compliant | No `eval()` or dangerous constructs | +| Clear title/description | ✅ Compliant | Comprehensive description | +| Issue addressed | ✅ Compliant | Explicitly stated in PR | +| How PR addresses it | ✅ Compliant | Detailed in Key Features section | +| Testing done | ✅ Compliant | 10 test scenarios provided | +| Potential concerns | ✅ Compliant | Explicit section added | + +## Ready to Proceed + +Everything is prepared and ready. The only remaining step is creating the Feature Request issue on GitHub, then updating the PR description with the issue number. + diff --git a/PR_SUBMISSION_CHECKLIST.md b/PR_SUBMISSION_CHECKLIST.md index 7ff02eaee..1140ea31e 100644 --- a/PR_SUBMISSION_CHECKLIST.md +++ b/PR_SUBMISSION_CHECKLIST.md @@ -72,33 +72,54 @@ The complete PR description is in `PR_DESCRIPTION.md` and includes: - [x] All changes committed to `preinstall-enhancements` branch - [x] Branch is based on `master` -- [x] PR description written +- [x] PR description written with all required sections - [x] Plan document included - [x] Code tested +- [x] Feature Request issue content created (`FEATURE_REQUEST_ISSUE.md`) +- [x] Issue creation instructions created (`CREATE_ISSUE_INSTRUCTIONS.md`) +- [x] PR compliance analysis completed (`PR_COMPLIANCE_ANALYSIS.md`) +- [ ] **Create Feature Request issue on GitHub** (REQUIRED - see instructions below) +- [ ] Update PR description with issue number after issue is created - [ ] Screenshots captured (optional but recommended) - [ ] Final review of PR description - [ ] Ready to submit to upstream repository ## Submission Steps -1. **Push branch to your fork**: - ```bash - git push origin preinstall-enhancements - ``` +### Step 1: Create Feature Request Issue (REQUIRED) -2. **Create PR on GitHub**: - - Go to the upstream repository - - Click "New Pull Request" - - Select `preinstall-enhancements` as source branch - - Select `master` as target branch - - Copy PR description from `PR_DESCRIPTION.md` - - Add screenshots if available - - Submit PR +**This must be done BEFORE submitting the PR to comply with contribution guidelines.** -3. **Monitor PR**: - - Respond to review comments - - Make requested changes if needed - - Update branch as necessary +1. Go to: https://github.com/comfyanonymous/ComfyUI/issues/new +2. Use title: `Feature Request: Enhanced run_comfyui.bat with Automated Dependency Checking and CUDA PyTorch Detection` +3. Copy content from `FEATURE_REQUEST_ISSUE.md` and paste into issue body +4. Submit the issue +5. **Save the issue number** (e.g., #12345) +6. Update `PR_DESCRIPTION.md` to replace the placeholder with: `Addresses #[issue-number]` +7. Commit the update: `git commit -am "Add issue number to PR description"` + +See `CREATE_ISSUE_INSTRUCTIONS.md` for detailed steps. + +### Step 2: Push Branch to Fork + +```bash +git push origin preinstall-enhancements +``` + +### Step 3: Create PR on GitHub + +1. Go to: https://github.com/comfyanonymous/ComfyUI/compare +2. Select `preinstall-enhancements` as source branch +3. Select `master` as target branch +4. Copy PR description from `PR_DESCRIPTION.md` (with issue number included) +5. Add screenshots if available +6. Submit PR + +### Step 4: Monitor PR + +- Respond to review comments +- Make requested changes if needed +- Update branch as necessary ## Notes