Update submission checklist and add final summary

- Updated PR_SUBMISSION_CHECKLIST.md with Feature Request issue creation step
- Added FINAL_SUMMARY.md with complete status and next steps
- All documentation and preparation complete
This commit is contained in:
John-Caldwell 2025-11-10 18:00:29 -06:00
parent 55b7ea2bbd
commit 04139fe528
2 changed files with 144 additions and 17 deletions

106
FINAL_SUMMARY.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,106 @@
# Final Summary - Preinstall Enhancements PR Preparation
## Status: ✅ READY FOR ISSUE CREATION
All preparation work is complete. The PR is ready once the Feature Request issue is created.
## Completed Tasks
### ✅ Code Implementation
- Enhanced `run_comfyui.bat` with all features
- Created `create_shortcut.ps1` helper script
- All code tested and working
### ✅ Documentation
- **PR_DESCRIPTION.md**: Complete PR description with all required sections:
- Author's Note
- Related Issue (placeholder for issue number)
- Issue Addressed
- Overview
- Key Features (5 major features)
- Files Changed
- Screenshots (with examples)
- Testing Recommendations (10 scenarios)
- Technical Details
- Backward Compatibility
- Benefits
- Additional Notes
- Potential Concerns and Side Effects
- Request for Review
- **FEATURE_REQUEST_ISSUE.md**: Complete issue content ready to copy/paste
- **CREATE_ISSUE_INSTRUCTIONS.md**: Step-by-step instructions for creating the issue
- **PR_SUBMISSION_CHECKLIST.md**: Complete checklist with updated steps
- **PR_COMPLIANCE_ANALYSIS.md**: Analysis of compliance with wiki requirements
- **SEARCH_RESULTS_SUMMARY.md**: Documentation of search for existing issues/PRs
- **PREINSTALL_ENHANCEMENTS_PLAN.md**: Plan document
### ✅ Compliance Verification
- ✅ No sensitive code (`eval()` not used)
- ✅ Clear title and comprehensive description
- ✅ All required sections included in PR description
- ✅ Testing recommendations provided
- ✅ Potential concerns explicitly stated
- ✅ PR size acknowledged with explanation
- ⚠️ Feature Request issue needs to be created (content ready)
### ✅ Branch Status
- Branch: `preinstall-enhancements`
- Base: `master`
- Status: Clean working tree, all changes committed
- Commits: 7 commits ready
- Files changed: 5 files (+725/-61 lines)
## Next Steps (In Order)
1. **Create Feature Request Issue** (REQUIRED)
- Use content from `FEATURE_REQUEST_ISSUE.md`
- Follow instructions in `CREATE_ISSUE_INSTRUCTIONS.md`
- Save the issue number
2. **Update PR Description**
- Replace placeholder in `PR_DESCRIPTION.md` with actual issue number
- Commit the update
3. **Push Branch**
```bash
git push origin preinstall-enhancements
```
4. **Create PR on GitHub**
- Use PR description from `PR_DESCRIPTION.md`
- Reference the issue number
- Add screenshots if available
## Files Ready for Use
1. **FEATURE_REQUEST_ISSUE.md** - Copy/paste into GitHub issue
2. **PR_DESCRIPTION.md** - Copy/paste into PR description (after adding issue number)
3. **CREATE_ISSUE_INSTRUCTIONS.md** - Step-by-step guide
4. **PR_SUBMISSION_CHECKLIST.md** - Complete checklist
## Key Points
- ✅ All wiki requirements met (except issue creation, which is next step)
- ✅ PR description is comprehensive and includes all required sections
- ✅ No duplicate work found (searched for existing issues/PRs)
- ✅ Code is tested and ready
- ✅ Documentation is complete
## Compliance Summary
| Requirement | Status | Notes |
|------------|--------|-------|
| Open Feature Request | ⚠️ Pending | Content ready, needs to be created |
| Single, focused PR | ✅ Compliant | Large but cohesive, explained in PR |
| No sensitive code | ✅ Compliant | No `eval()` or dangerous constructs |
| Clear title/description | ✅ Compliant | Comprehensive description |
| Issue addressed | ✅ Compliant | Explicitly stated in PR |
| How PR addresses it | ✅ Compliant | Detailed in Key Features section |
| Testing done | ✅ Compliant | 10 test scenarios provided |
| Potential concerns | ✅ Compliant | Explicit section added |
## Ready to Proceed
Everything is prepared and ready. The only remaining step is creating the Feature Request issue on GitHub, then updating the PR description with the issue number.

View File

@ -72,30 +72,51 @@ The complete PR description is in `PR_DESCRIPTION.md` and includes:
- [x] All changes committed to `preinstall-enhancements` branch - [x] All changes committed to `preinstall-enhancements` branch
- [x] Branch is based on `master` - [x] Branch is based on `master`
- [x] PR description written - [x] PR description written with all required sections
- [x] Plan document included - [x] Plan document included
- [x] Code tested - [x] Code tested
- [x] Feature Request issue content created (`FEATURE_REQUEST_ISSUE.md`)
- [x] Issue creation instructions created (`CREATE_ISSUE_INSTRUCTIONS.md`)
- [x] PR compliance analysis completed (`PR_COMPLIANCE_ANALYSIS.md`)
- [ ] **Create Feature Request issue on GitHub** (REQUIRED - see instructions below)
- [ ] Update PR description with issue number after issue is created
- [ ] Screenshots captured (optional but recommended) - [ ] Screenshots captured (optional but recommended)
- [ ] Final review of PR description - [ ] Final review of PR description
- [ ] Ready to submit to upstream repository - [ ] Ready to submit to upstream repository
## Submission Steps ## Submission Steps
1. **Push branch to your fork**: ### Step 1: Create Feature Request Issue (REQUIRED)
**This must be done BEFORE submitting the PR to comply with contribution guidelines.**
1. Go to: https://github.com/comfyanonymous/ComfyUI/issues/new
2. Use title: `Feature Request: Enhanced run_comfyui.bat with Automated Dependency Checking and CUDA PyTorch Detection`
3. Copy content from `FEATURE_REQUEST_ISSUE.md` and paste into issue body
4. Submit the issue
5. **Save the issue number** (e.g., #12345)
6. Update `PR_DESCRIPTION.md` to replace the placeholder with: `Addresses #[issue-number]`
7. Commit the update: `git commit -am "Add issue number to PR description"`
See `CREATE_ISSUE_INSTRUCTIONS.md` for detailed steps.
### Step 2: Push Branch to Fork
```bash ```bash
git push origin preinstall-enhancements git push origin preinstall-enhancements
``` ```
2. **Create PR on GitHub**: ### Step 3: Create PR on GitHub
- Go to the upstream repository
- Click "New Pull Request" 1. Go to: https://github.com/comfyanonymous/ComfyUI/compare
- Select `preinstall-enhancements` as source branch 2. Select `preinstall-enhancements` as source branch
- Select `master` as target branch 3. Select `master` as target branch
- Copy PR description from `PR_DESCRIPTION.md` 4. Copy PR description from `PR_DESCRIPTION.md` (with issue number included)
- Add screenshots if available 5. Add screenshots if available
- Submit PR 6. Submit PR
### Step 4: Monitor PR
3. **Monitor PR**:
- Respond to review comments - Respond to review comments
- Make requested changes if needed - Make requested changes if needed
- Update branch as necessary - Update branch as necessary